Do I Need an Agent, Brand Manager, or NIL Consultant? What Athletes Should Know
- Dolomites Consulting Team
- Apr 22
- 3 min read
The NIL era has opened doors for student-athletes to build personal brands, secure sponsorships, and create long-term career opportunities. But with so many options available, one of the first key questions athletes face is: Who should I work with? An agent? A brand manager? Or something else?
Making the right decision early can set the foundation for lasting success — not just quick deals. Here’s a clear breakdown of the key differences between these roles to help you make the smartest move for your NIL journey.
1. Understand the Key Differences 💡
While agents, brand managers, and consultants all support your NIL career, they serve very different roles. Understanding how each one works can help you build the right team at the right time.
What an Agent Typically Does:
Negotiates deals and contract terms
Manages legal and financial aspects of endorsements
Secures sponsorship and licensing opportunities
May handle professional sports contract negotiations after college
In simple terms: Agents focus on closing deals. Their role is primarily transaction-based, ensuring you get favorable contract terms once opportunities come in.
What a Brand Manager Typically Does:
Builds and grows your personal brand
Develops long-term marketing and content strategy
Creates and oversees consistent content and messaging
Manages your overall image across social media, partnerships, and media outlets
In simple terms: Brand managers help you grow your audience, improve your online presence, and create the kind of consistent, professional image that attracts sponsors over time.
What a NIL Consultant Typically Does:
Defines your personal brand identity, values, and positioning
Creates full-scale NIL growth strategy across content, partnerships, and outreach
Supports brand deal development and partnership outreach
Acts as a mentor and advisor to help you pivot and evolve as your career grows
Coordinates with outside professionals (legal, financial, agents) as your needs change
Provides ongoing support to protect long-term interests, not just short-term earnings
In simple terms: A NIL consultant offers full-spectrum guidance across brand building, partnerships, and business development. They help you build smart, adapt as you grow, and bring in specialized support when needed, without locking you into exclusive contracts too early.
2. You May Not Need an Agent Right Away
Many athletes assume they need to hire an agent immediately. But if you’re just starting out with small or local deals, you may not need an agent yet.
Early NIL deals are often straightforward and don’t require complex negotiations.
You may be better served by having a consultant or legal advisor review any early contracts.
Agents typically become more valuable as your deals grow in size and complexity.
Rushing into agent contracts too early can lock you into long-term agreements before you fully understand your brand’s long-term value.
3. Why Many Athletes Benefit From Starting with a Consultant
A NIL consultant provides the flexible, strategic support that most young athletes need early in their careers.
Helps build your personal brand foundation.
Guides you on content creation, messaging, and audience growth.
Supports brand outreach and partnership discussions.
Coaches you as you navigate early opportunities.
Allows you to stay in control while surrounding you with trusted expertise.
For most student-athletes, working with a consultant offers the best blend of mentorship, brand-building support, and deal-readiness — without the pressure of exclusive contracts too early.
4. You May Eventually Build a Full Team of Advisors
As your career and NIL opportunities grow, you may eventually need multiple professionals supporting you. Many top athletes build a trusted team that includes:
An agent for high-level contract negotiations
A brand manager or content team for consistent media presence
A NIL consultant who remains your long-term strategic advisor
Legal and financial experts to manage contracts, taxes, and business planning
The most successful athletes don’t build this team all at once, they grow smart, bringing in the right expertise at the right time as their opportunities expand.
Final Thoughts
Choosing who supports your NIL journey is one of the most important decisions you’ll make. Agents, brand managers, and consultants each serve a purpose, but most young athletes benefit from starting with flexible, full-spectrum guidance that allows their brand to evolve.
At Dolomites Consulting Group, we serve as NIL consultants and personal brand advisors, helping athletes build sustainable brands, secure the right partnerships, and make smart long-term decisions that go far beyond quick sponsorships.
Comments